Buying vs. renting is one of the most common questions people ask me. Personally, I believe it’s best to rent. I live in a small apartment in San Jose, CA, and I live in a large house with my family in Oregon. The reason is I believe the value of a home is like a mutual fund, where you are investing into your home. If you rent, you are simply getting the use of the property. When you buy a home, you are investing into the home.

Renting can be a great option for people who don’t have much cash to spare and are planning on living in an apartment for a while, or if you’re simply worried about losing your investment if you rent and buy a home later on down the road. There are several factors to consider when deciding whether to rent or buy, but the two main differences that you’re probably familiar with are maintenance and tax. When comparing the two options, it’s important to remember that the average house in the U.S. generally costs more than the average apartment, so if you’re looking to save money, it’s not always the best idea to buy.

So a lot of money is being spent on buying cars these days. And not just the ones that belong to the likes of the Kardashians (though I’m sure that’s an upside of that kind of spending). Lots of people are buying cars, and some of them are being really frugal when it comes to their car-buying habits. They’re not buying the biggest, most expensive cars on the market. They’re taking the time to research different models when they go to a car dealership. They’re looking for models that have lower monthly payments and higher returns on their investment. They’re being smart about their car-buying decisions, which is a good thing.. Read more about renting is cheaper than buying, almost everywhere and let us know what you think.

Is Renting Cheaper Than Buying

My parents put forth a lot of effort while I was growing up to purchase their first house together. That first home is still fresh in my mind. Knowing they owned it and could make whatever changes they wanted gave them such a feeling of pride. I knew I wanted to buy my own house when I was an adult and moved out on my own.

Unfortunately, I was unaware for how costly buying a house might be. Everything was simply too much to handle, from the down payment and insurance to the closing fees and, of course, the beginning expenditures. Even the monthly payments were more than I could afford.

I felt compelled to rent an apartment merely because it was the most affordable choice. I grew to enjoy my flats over time, but I still bought a house when I was financially ready.

Whether you’re trying to figure out what works best for you, you may be wondering if renting is less expensive than purchasing. Renting, in fact, offers a number of financial benefits that smart buyers may take advantage of if they aren’t in a position to buy a house right now. On a monthly and upfront basis, it may be less costly.

Here’s everything you need to know about renting vs. purchasing before you make a snap choice.

Get Your Free Money Management and Investing Guide

Is it cheaper to rent than to buy?

If you’ve been paying attention to current real estate market trends, you’ve probably noticed that it’s a seller’s market. In a nutshell, a seller’s market occurs when there are fewer houses available than there are buyers.

People are scooping up houses left and right right now, with many properties selling for more than the asking amount. Housing prices are at an all-time high in this highly competitive market. As a result, many individuals question whether renting is really less expensive than buying a house.

The typical rental price is considerably less costly than the median mortgage cost, according to a new research by Lending Tree. To examine how the statistics stood up, they compared the fifty biggest metropolitan regions.

Lending Tree discovered that renting was $606 less expensive than paying off a mortgage on a monthly basis. Major cities such as New York and San Francisco experienced significant monthly disparities of over $1,200.

However, the monthly cost isn’t the only factor to consider. When deciding whether to buy or rent a house, you must consider the upfront expenses. When you buy anything, you’ll need to put down a deposit, which is typically between 3.5 and 20% of the purchase price (unless you are using mortgage products like a VA loan).

A down payment of $8,750 to $50,000 is required for a $250,000 property. That’s a significant sum of money that you probably don’t have in your bank account.

When you buy a house, you must either pay for the closing fees upfront or roll them into your mortgage. These may amount to an extra 3% to 4% of your buying price ($7,500 to $10,000 in our example). Attorney fees, appraisals, taxes, and title insurance are examples of closing costs that you may incur while buying a home.

Rentals, on the other hand, usually just need a security deposit and the first month’s rent. Depending on your credit, some homes may additionally need the last month’s rent. Given that this is about three months’ worth of rent, it may be a substantial savings over putting down the money required to close on a house.

Because buying a house needs such a large sum of money up front, it is only a smart choice if you want to live there for a long time. You will lose all of the money you put down for closing fees if you sell the house within the first couple of years. Closing charges may be very costly.

To assist offset the initial cost, it is advised that you only buy a house if you intend to remain there for three years or more. Renting offers you more flexibility and freedom to move about as you want.

Renting Has Extra Expenses

On the other hand, there’s more to your monthly rent payment than meets the eye as well. While your monthly expenditures should definitely be taken into account, you should also budget for additional expenses. When you sign a new lease, you’ll usually be charged these one-time fees.

Fees for applications

Before you receive the keys to your first apartment or rental property, you’ll typically have to pay an application fee. The majority of businesses demand an application fee simply to be evaluated as a potential renter. The expenses of a background check and a credit check are covered by application fees.

This assists property owners in determining if you are at danger of missing a payment. The application cost is typically low, ranging between $20 and $80 depending on your location.

We had to pay an application fee to be considered for our previous apartment, and we had to pay it to be considered for the lease. People who worked in specific areas, such as first responders, received a discount on the application cost. Always inquire about any possible reductions on the application cost to assist you save a little cash.

Deposits of Security

You are accountable for the general condition of things if you own your house. You are the only one who will bear the financial burden of putting the place back together if you ruin it. Rentals aren’t the same as owning a home. Many individuals tend to live recklessly and destroy the property since the renter is not financially liable for repairs.

A security deposit is intended to provide some redress for the owners and to assist pay the expense of any damage you do to the property. It typically amounts to roughly a month’s worth of rent.

I had to put down some substantial security deposits when I initially started out and had no credit. It was about equivalent to two months’ rent in my first apartment. Things did, however, improve with time. Because of my excellent credit score, I was able to have the security deposit removed in several of the apartments I’ve resided in.

When your lease ends, the property owner or landlord may even return your security deposit. Make careful to inquire about the possibility of a lower security deposit in specific situations.

is renting cheaper than buying

Deposits for Pets

When you own your own house, you have the flexibility to do anything you want with it, including acquiring a four-legged companion. If renters want to keep Fido in their apartment or rental property, they may have to jump through extra hoops.

Dogs and cats cause more wear and strain on the property, including scraped flooring, pet stains on carpets, and damage to doors and window sills. A few hundred dollars more (non-refundable) may be charged by your landlord simply to maintain a single pet in your flat.

Even when we lived in an apartment, we always had several pets. When you have several dogs, you have multiple pet deposits, which may quickly mount up when you move as often as we did. Make sure you verify with the landlord before you decide to move in since our average pet deposit was approximately $250 per dog.

Insurance for Renters

Most rental homes need renter’s insurance, which is a very modest expense. This protects you and your possessions in the event that anything bad occurs to the house while you’re living there.

It also covers you against theft, medical bills, and personal responsibility in the event that someone is hurt or their property is destroyed while you are at home or at your apartment. This typically costs $20 per month or less.

Get Your Free Money Management Guide Today!

Added Costs of Ownership

When it comes to buying a house, there are a number of extra costs that you should budget for. Renting is easier since there are less out-of-pocket costs apart from your monthly rent payment, but buying is far more involved.

Here are a few costs connected with house ownership that you may not have considered.

HOA Dues

The majority of rental homes do not require you to pay homeowner’s association (HOA) dues. For single-family houses, the average HOA cost is about $200. If you have your heart set on a condo, be prepared to spend much more money. HOA dues for many of these kinds of properties are in the $500 level.

Keep in mind that these figures may change depending on where you reside and the neighborhood you choose to buy in. HOA dues are often higher in communities with more facilities, such as pools or tennis courts, to pay the expense of upkeep.

We were very fortunate when purchasing our first house, since we were able to buy a property with no HOA fees. It wasn’t in a community and didn’t have any facilities that were provided by someone else. This was a fantastic method for us to save a little more cash every month.

Just keep in mind that finding a house without HOA dues is feasible, though it may be more challenging.

And if you don’t have a HOA, you’ll be responsible for the home’s daily or monthly upkeep, which may include mowing the lawn, trimming the hedges, and other tasks that will take up some of your time and money in the long term.


If you rent a property, obtaining a repair is often as simple as dialing your landlord’s number. They are in charge of hiring the professional and paying the cost. If you own the property outright, you’ll be the one who is ultimately liable for all of the repairs.

This may be advantageous since you can select trustworthy contractors and arrange the work around your timetable. However, when the repair is completed, it will cost you money.

Taxes on real estate

Your property taxes are likely the second biggest housing expense after your mortgage and interest payments. Expect to spend hundreds of dollars each month in property taxes when you buy a house. 1.07 percent of the buying price is the national average.

This implies that a $250,000 house would cost $2,675 in taxes each year, or approximately $222 more per month. While property taxes are usually included in your rent, if you buy a house, you will be responsible for paying them on your own.

Mortgage Protection Insurance

Private mortgage insurance (PMI) is a method for a lender to protect themselves if you fail on your mortgage payment. It usually comes into play when you put down a lower down payment, less than 20% of the home’s worth.

This is an out-of-pocket cost that will not be included in your rent payment. PMI usually costs between 0.5 and 1.8 percent of your home’s purchasing price each year.

We had to determine if we wanted to spend more of our money on our second house in order to put down a bigger down payment and avoid PMI. We calculated how much PMI would cost us on a monthly basis (about $100) and concluded it was worthwhile to put more money down. However, our savings account was soon depleted as a result of this.

We justified the higher down payment by calculating how much money we would save monthly and over time. PMI, after all, serves no use for homeowners. It is basically money wasted since it solely helps to protect the lender.

Is renting cheaper than buying

Insurance for Homeowners

Renter’s insurance, which may be very cheap, is almost certainly required in a rented property. You must have a homeowner’s insurance coverage on your house after you have purchased it.

This is needed to safeguard the lender’s interests in the case of a disaster at your house, such as a hurricane, tornado, or even a fallen tree.

On a $250,000 house, the typical insurance coverage costs approximately $1,300 per year (a little more than $100 per month). Renter’s insurance, on the other hand, is often less than $20 per month. As a result, this cost is considerably more than what you would have to pay if you were renting.

The Process Is Different

There is a distinction between renting and purchasing a house. Purchasing a house requires considerably more effort. Lenders are more stricter about who they allow to buy a house than landlords are about who they rent to for a short time.

Here are the main distinctions between renting and purchasing a home.


When you wish to rent a home, you must first fill out an application. The landlord or leasing business will do a background check to look into your criminal past, credit history, and any prior eviction history you may have. Typically, you will be charged a modest fee to cover the expense of this service.

If everything seems to be in order, you will begin the process of putting together a lease. This is where you’ll learn more about the security deposit and any additional money required to sign the lease.

The amount of your security deposit is often determined by your credit score, with poorer credit ratings needing larger payments. If you have any outstanding pet deposits, now is the time to pay them.

Finally, you’ll sign a lease for a certain length of time. You have the option of renewing your lease at the conclusion of the term. However, you should be aware that at the conclusion of each agreement, the landlord usually retains the right to modify the rental amount.

Because of this price volatility, many individuals prefer the notion of buying their own house, where their mortgage payments would remain stable for decades.

We relocated a lot throughout the winter while we were renting flats since they were cheaper at that time of year. Nobody wants to relocate over the holidays, after all. Because the leasing agency was ready to go to any length to fill empty apartments, we often received exceptional offers.

They would attempt to increase the prices to the current market value every year when our lease was up, and we would have to relocate to a new apartment. It was a major pain, but it saved us hundreds of dollars each month and was well worth it in the end.


If you want to buy a house, the best thing you can do is meet with a lender as soon as possible. Before deciding whether you are pre-approved for a loan, they will do a comparable check on your credit and financial history.

This pre-approval informs you of your budget for purchasing a new house, allowing you to begin looking with a real estate agent.

You’ll need to provide the lender with everything they need to get your final approval while you’re looking for the house of your dreams. Bank statements, tax returns, and pay stubs will be required. Lenders will also check your job and make sure you have adequate money put up for the down payment.

You will make an offer after you have found the house you want. The property will be under contract if the existing owner accepts your offer.

You will have the option of having the house examined before to buying for an extra fee.

The process of purchasing a house may take months to complete. You and your attorney will attend the closing after all of the required inspections and documentation have been completed. This is the time to make your down payment and pay the closing fees. You will have signed on the dotted line after your visit, and the keys will be yours!

When looking for a home, there are a few things to keep in mind.

If you still believe that purchasing is the best option for you, make sure you choose a home that you can afford. These pointers will assist you in selecting the home of your dreams that you can afford.

HOA Dues are Reasonably Low

Look for a house with minimal to no HOA dues if you want to save money on a regular basis. If you live in a region with a lot of single-family homes that aren’t in a community, this is certainly a possibility.

HOA dues in certain communities with few facilities, such as pools or parks, are very cheap. As it did for us when we bought our first house, this may save you hundreds of dollars each year.

Newer Buildings

Looking at newer homes is another method to possibly save money on a home purchase. Homes that are either brand new or constructed within the last few years may help you save money on repair expenses.

Older houses, on the other hand, may be in need of additional repairs, such as malfunctioning hot water heaters, damaged HVAC systems, and outdated equipment like the stove or refrigerator.

We chose a new build property for our second home since it meant less money would be spent on expensive maintenance. Everything is brand new and protected by the manufacturer’s warranty. Before we have to pay for any repairs, we should have many years ahead of us.

While the property was initially more costly, the peace of mind that comes with knowing that everything is brand new and in good condition is worth it. In the next years, there will be fewer shocks.

Put money aside for a down payment.

If you think buying a house is in your future, you should start saving for the down payment right immediately. Put up a separate savings account for your down payment and closing expenses so you won’t be tempted to touch the money you set aside for them.

These may add up quickly, so be sure you put aside a reasonable amount of money each month. You may also boost your savings by cutting your monthly expenses or starting a side business.

Pro tip: treat your savings account as if it were another payment that has to be paid every month. This method of paying yourself guarantees that you are constantly putting money into your savings account. To make things even simpler, you may set up a regular transfer between your checking and savings accounts.

This is one method to watch your savings increase rather than wondering where all your extra cash went at the end of the month.

Get the Minority Mindset Money Management Guide

What Should You Do If You Can’t Decide Between Renting and Buying?

There is nothing intrinsically wrong with renting rather than owning a home. According to recent studies, renting a home is actually less costly than getting a mortgage. Rent and other upfront expenses like as down payments and closing charges will be lower.

You’re also not responsible for making repairs, paying the HOA, or paying the property taxes.

If you wish to rent a house, the procedure is a bit different and less complicated. You’ll have to jump through fewer hoops to verify your income and credit history. As a consequence, renting a house is frequently more convenient than purchasing a home, which may take months.

When you own a house, though, you may do almost whatever you want with it, such as make renovations or have numerous pets. You may also have fixed mortgage payments, which means your monthly payments will be the same year after year.

After your lease expires, your monthly payments in a rental may rise.

If you do decide to buy a house, seek for houses with minimal HOAs or search for newer homes to save money. If you believe that making a purchase is the best financial decision for you, start saving right immediately.

There is no right or wrong option, since both renting and purchasing will provide you with a unique experience. Examine your financial situation to determine whether you can afford one or the other. Consider contacting a lender to discuss your choices before making a purchase if you believe you may want to buy.

In any case, you’ll need to do some research to locate a nice and inexpensive house.

Continue reading:

  • What You Should Know About Rent-to-Own Homes: Do They Pay Off?
  • Pre-Approved Mortgage Loans for First-Time Homebuyers
  • Should I Buy or Rent a House?

Get the Minority Mindset Money Management and Investing Guide!

Is Renting Cheaper Than Buying? first published on Minority Mindset.

It is well known that renting is cheaper than buying, but is it really? To determine this, I looked at the average price of a house in the United States over the last 10 years. According to the National Association of Realtors, the average price of an existing single family house in the United States in 2005 was $196,000. This is almost identical to the price of an average new single family home in the United States, which was $176,000 in 2010. Therefore, we can conclude that the average price of an existing single family home in the United States has increased less than the average price of a new single family home.. Read more about renting vs buying pros and cons and let us know what you think.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better buying or renting?

Renting is better because you can save money and not have to worry about returning it.

Is renting always cheaper?

Renting is always cheaper than buying.

This article broadly covered the following related topics:

  • is renting cheaper than buying
  • rent vs buy calculator
  • renting vs buying
  • rent vs buy calculator zillow
  • rent vs buy 2019
You May Also Like

Groundfloor vs. Fundrise 2022 | Which Platform is Better?

Groundfloor and Fundrise are both equity crowdfunding platforms that let investors invest…

Is Left Hand Itching Lottery Luck? (What your itchy left hand means for your money in 2021)

A trip to the doctor for some sort of rash or infection…

How to Prepare For an Emergency

The most important thing you can do for your personal security is…