Amelia is a small island in Florida, which makes it one of the best places to live and retire. It has great weather, accessible beaches and an excellent education system. Some people argue that life on Amelia Island can be too idyllic with no real work or challenges; others point out how wonderful this place would be for retirees who want to enjoy life without stress.;

Amelia Island is a small island off the coast of Florida. The island has many pros and cons that make it appealing to live on.

15 Pros and Cons of Living on Amelia Island in Florida

Is it a good idea to relocate from Amelia Island to Fernandina Beach?

If the idea of living on an island appeals to you. Then you should think about the advantages and disadvantages of residing on Amelia Island. In or around Fernandina Beach, Florida.

We’re referring to the 13-mile-long barrier island off Florida’s northeast coast. Only a few miles south of the Georgia state border.

It is a popular location for families and retirees. And it has a resort-like ambiance all year.

However, the Amelia Island way of life isn’t for everyone. So think about the advantages and disadvantages…

The Benefits and Drawbacks of Living on Amelia Island

  • Different towns are available to choose from.
  • Excellent weather
  • There are several outdoor activities available.
  • Beautiful beaches
  • Family-Friendly
  • Jacksonville is close by.
  • There are There are no state income taxes..
  • Cost of living is really high.
  • Housing stock that is older
  • New construction is limited.
  • Severe weather danger
  • Several complaints about bad scents have been made.
  • There isn’t much variety.
  • There are a lot of visitors and snowbirds.
  • Off-island traffic is bad.


I may get compensation for purchases made via links in this article at no cost to you.

Before we proceed any further, let’s have a look at the following. And, just in case you had any concerns, here’s a little peek at what’s to come.

Make sure to take a look at all we have to offer…

Places To Live Guideposts

Otherwise, please stick with me for the time being. As we go more into the benefits and drawbacks of relocating to Amelia Island.

Let’s go through them one by one…

Different towns are available to choose from.

Amelia Island is a tiny village on the coast of Florida’s Nassau County.

You have the option of living in historic Fernandina Beach.

The island’s biggest and most well-known town. There are hundreds of privately owned stores and eateries in the downtown area.

There’s also Amelia City. Then there’s American Beach, which is located on the Atlantic Ocean’s coastlines. Or, to the south, Franklintown.

Excellent weather

You will benefit from the good weather by migrating to this northern Florida beach neighborhood.

Yes. In the summer, it does become hot.

With an average high temperature of 90 degrees, it’s going to be a hot day. It’s ideal for a day at the beach.

However, the actual feel temps are far more pleasant because to the seaside breezes. Compared to the state’s southern and interior areas.

Winters are also a lot of fun. Temperatures in the mid-60s are common throughout the day.

Lows in the 40s are expected at night. Perfect for anybody who needs a reminder that the seasons are still changing in the winter.

However, you won’t have to deal with any of the seasonal annoyances. Snow, ice, and sub-freezing temperatures all contribute to this.

Furthermore, the weather encourages people to go outside. On Amelia Island, there are lots of things to do…

There are several outdoor activities available.

Of course, there are several water activities to choose from. Kayaking, fishing, sailing, surfing, and boating are just a few of the activities available.

You may stroll across the lovely parks. Fort Clinch State Park and Amelia Island State Park, for example.

Hiking, motorcycling, birdwatching, and enjoying the water features are all popular activities in these areas.

Golf enthusiasts will be spoiled for choice. Championship courses, exclusive golf clubs, and public links are all available.

Finally, if you like horseback riding. This is a unique location where you may ride a horse on the beach.

Aside from that, numerous residential neighborhoods are created around excellent golf courses.

I also had to separate the following outside activity into its own segment. Because you’ll be living on an Atlantic Ocean island.

So, this could be the nicest part about relocating here…

Beautiful beaches

Because it doesn’t matter where you reside on Amelia Island. You’ll be close to the beach from here.

Because the land area at its broadest point is barely 4 miles across. From the Amelia River to the Atlantic Ocean, this stretch of land stretches for miles.

So you can walk to the beach from almost everywhere.

The following are some of the nicest local beaches:

  • Burney Park is a park in New York City.
  • Beach Park (Main)
  • The Opinion of Peter
  • Park by the Sea

You should also visit Little Talbot Island State Park, which is located right off the coast of Amelia Island. Miles of pristine white sand beaches can be found there.

So far, you may have concluded that Amelia Island is an excellent holiday destination. And you wouldn’t be entirely incorrect.

You may, however, settle down and start a family here. Some of the additional benefits of residing on Amelia Island are…



What youngster wouldn’t want to grow up in a seaside town in Florida? That would be fantastic in my opinion.

However, children cannot spend the whole week playing in the sand. So, when kids start school, you can be comfortable that they will have access to some excellent educational opportunities.

First and foremost, Nassau’s public schools are regarded as excellent. The school district operates on a “single feeder” system. As your children go through grades and schools, allow them to form enduring connections.

Eventually, he will attend Fernandina Beach High School. The island’s lone secondary school. Nearly 1,000 pupils attend this school.

There are also a number of private schools in the area. They typically serve students in grades K through 8.

Following that, you won’t have to be concerned about crime. Or you may be concerned about the safety of your family.

Because both property and violent crime are at historically low levels. In comparison to the national and Florida averages.

Finally, there are several excellent health-care alternatives in the neighborhood. For when you or the kids have problems. Jacksonville has a plethora of fantastic amenities.

In relation to that…

You simply have to go away from time to time. Regardless of how much you like the Amelia Island way of life.

As a result, here’s another one of the advantages of living here…

Jacksonville is close by.

Because of the Jacksonville is close by.. The most populated city in the state of Florida.

There is a big-city atmosphere there. There are several urban facilities. There are lots of entertaining things to do as well as professional athletic events.

The island is just a little more than 30 miles from downtown Jacksonville. It all depends on where you’re coming from.

Residents of Amelia Island may also take advantage of the thriving Jacksonville employment market.

As a result, there will be opportunities for work in major cities. While residing on a tranquil Florida island that resembles a resort.

Does this seem to be the ideal pairing for you?

Perhaps. Particularly if you can find a job that allows you to work from home one or more days each week.

Let’s speak about money next…

There are There are no state income taxes..

Because Florida is one of just a few states that does not levy an income tax on its inhabitants. As a result, in Amelia Island, you may stretch your retirement income or your salaries a bit farther.

Depending on the state from where you are relocating. Also, how much money do you earn? It’s possible to save a lot of money on taxes.

Now, since we’re on the subject of money, let’s move on to the next point. It’s an excellent segue into the difficulties of living on Amelia Island.

I’m sure you knew it wasn’t ideal, right? And it isn’t.

So, let’s round off this discussion with the drawbacks of living here…


Cost of living is really high.

Using the cost of living in Fernandina Beach as a benchmark, you’ll discover that it’s an expensive area to live in Florida.

The average living expense is 22 percent greater than the national average, according to In addition, the median property price is 50% greater than the national average.

As a consequence, living on an island off the Atlantic coast offers its benefits. Saving money on your living expenditures, on the other hand, isn’t one of them.

Because almost everything is more costly here. Let’s start with real estate. In comparison to other Florida towns, cities, and regions.

As a result, the average Amelia Island resident is quite wealthy. With incomes and assets in the elite echelon of American citizens.

So, before you relocate, make sure your financial home is in order.

Personal Capital’s online tool is ideal for this. It allows us to keep track of all of our financial operations in one spot.

To view our expenditures, budget, and investments in one place.

Next, there will be a disadvantage to living on Amelia Island for individuals who like new building and commercial growth…

Housing stock that is older

When searching for a place to live. If you like new building, this is the place to be. You won’t find much of that in this area.

Because the majority of the properties for sale were constructed before to the year 2000.

As a result, you may want to live off the island to the west for modern houses and communities. Yulee is a little closer.

New construction is limited.

Big box businesses and chain eateries are in the same boat. Because Amelia Island hasn’t seen that kind of major commercial growth.

That may be a good thing, depending on your point of view.

On the other hand, if you live in a community with a Home Depot and a Super Walmart, you’re in luck. That isn’t something you’ll discover here.

As a result, be ready to get in the automobile. The Amelia River is crossed. And I’m on my way to Yulee.

Severe weather danger

Hurricanes are a constant threat in Florida, no matter where you live.

And, of course, this is a barrier island in the Atlantic Ocean. One of these catastrophic storms is a distinct possibility in this area. During hurricane season every year.

The good news is that the region hasn’t been struck directly in recorded history.

Rain, wind, and floods, on the other hand, might cause collateral damage. Storm activity has been reported all around the eastern shore.

Several complaints about bad scents have been made.

In the region of Amelia Concourse and Route 200, not far from the island. Foul scents have been reported by residents.

A sludge site from previous industrial activities was blamed. In Fernandina Beach, there is also a paper mill near the Amelia River.

It, too, may emit some odd odors.

So, keep this in mind while shopping for a property. There has been industrial activity in and around the region in the past.

There isn’t much variety.

If you like being in an environment with a wide range of individuals. When you live on Amelia Island, you won’t be able to locate it.

Because the majority of the residents are elderly, wealthy white people.

White people account for more than 80% of the population. And the typical age of individuals who live there is about 55.

There are a lot of visitors and snowbirds.

If you choose to reside on this island community, you are picking one of Florida’s most popular vacation spots. The location has drawn 700,000 overnight guests in peak years.

Some inhabitants also live here on a part-time basis. During the colder months of the year.

If transients and a shifting population aren’t your thing, this isn’t the place for you. Then this island could or might not be a good fit for you.

Finally, there’s one additional disadvantage to coming to Amelia Island…

Off-island traffic is bad.

Off the island, particularly in and around the Jacksonville metropolitan region, is a good idea. You’ll also have to contend with considerable traffic congestion here.

During the peak winter season, it is at its harshest. When the number of tourists and part-time inhabitants increases.

The same may be said about living in Fernandina Beach. Especially during holiday weekends, in and around downtown. There will be a lot of tourist traffic at those hours.

Okay. That’s all I’ve got.

Allow me to conclude with a few more ideas…

Pros and Cons of Living on Amelia Island

Thank you for taking the time to read about life on Amelia Island, particularly in Fernandina Beach, the island’s major municipality.

Is Amelia Island a decent location to reside for someone who has this question?

I hope you found the advantages and disadvantages to be useful.

It’s difficult for me to find fault with a family-friendly, laid-back seaside town with a safe resort-like vibe. There are several possibilities to enjoy the great outdoors.

The Amelia Island lifestyle, like any other, is not for everyone. So, before migrating here, think about the possible negatives.

Finally, for everyone still looking for the ideal spot to call home. Take a look at what we have to offer…

Living Guides for States and Cities

1629658693_67_10-Pros-and-Cons-of-Living-in-New-Hampshire-RightOn a whiteboard, the conclusion is written.

Disclosure & Disclaimer: I am not a licensed investment adviser, financial adviser, or tax professional. And I am not providing you with individual investment advice, financial guidance, or tax counsel. Furthermore, this website’s only purpose is information & entertainment. And we are not liable for any losses suffered by any party because of information published on this blog.

Pros and Cons of Living on Amelia Island, Including Fernandina Beach


The “best neighborhoods in fernandina beach, fl” is a list of pros and cons that one should consider before moving to Amelia Island.

  • pros and cons of living in fernandina beach, fl
  • amelia island cost of living
  • best neighborhoods in amelia island, fl
  • amelia island crime
  • fernandina beach living reviews
You May Also Like

11 Relaxing Ways to Get Paid to Go on Vacation This Year

There are plenty of ways you can earn enough to get away…

Things You Should Consider Before Investing in Cryptocurrency

Cryptocurrency can be a very lucrative investment. However, like any investment, cryptocurrency…

Jobs for Felons in Omaha, Nebraska

A new study by the Economic Policy Institute reveals that even after…

Moomoo Review 2021 | Designed For High-Volume Trading

Moomoo Review 2021 | Designed For High-Volume Trading Moomoo Review 2021 |…